DIY Magnetic Screen Doors vs. Phantom Retractable Screen Doors: Which Is Right for You?

If you’re looking to add a screen door to your home, you’re likely considering two popular options: budget-friendly DIY magnetic screen doors and high-end Phantom Retractable Screen doors. Both offer insect protection and increased ventilation, but they differ greatly in durability, aesthetics, convenience, and long-term value. In this blog post, we’ll break down the pros and cons of each option to help you make the best choice for your home.

• Affordable: Most magnetic screen doors cost between $20 and $50.
• Easy Installation: Typically installs with Velcro or adhesive strips in minutes.
• Hands-Free Use: Magnets allow for easy entry and exit without using your hands.

• Limited Durability: Thin mesh and cheap stitching can wear out quickly.
• Poor Aesthetics: Often looks temporary and may not blend well with your home’s exterior.
• Weak Seals: Gaps can form around edges, making them less effective at keeping bugs out.
• Not Pet-Proof: Easily torn by dogs or cats pushing through.

• Sleek Design: Retracts out of sight when not in use, preserving your doorway’s appearance.
• Custom Fit: Professionally installed to ensure a tight, secure fit with no gaps.
• Long-Lasting: High-quality materials and components built for years of use.
• Pet & Child Friendly: More durable against wear and accidental bumps.

• Higher Cost: Prices typically range from $400 to $600 installed.
• Professional Installation Required: Not a DIY-friendly option.
• Lead Time: May involve scheduling and waiting for installation.

If you’re a renter or need a quick, low-cost screen solution, a DIY magnetic screen door may be a good temporary fix. However, if you’re a homeowner seeking a more permanent, stylish, and reliable solution, the Phantom Retractable Screen door is the superior choice.

While magnetic screens can serve in a pinch, they often fall short in performance and longevity. Phantom Retractable Screen doors offer a premium, seamless solution that enhances the look and feel of your home for years to come. For those interested in long-term value and durability, investing in a Phantom Screen through Broadview Screen is a decision you won’t regret.